Governing across the Divide: Restoring Civility to Public Discourse was the title of a program I recently attended at the Washington National Cathedral. The setting was appropriately awe-inspiring and the audience of Democrats, Republicans and Independents were sitting on the edge of their seats hoping David Axelrod, President Obama’s Senior Advisor, and John Bolton, Chief of Staff to former President George W. Bush, would somehow part the waters and free us all from the plague of nastiness that has infected the United States, and yes, Canada.
But no, their comments were safe and at times trivial. To restore civility one would have to admit a role in creating the incivility – impossible to do weeks away from a very important midterm election.
By far the most moving and powerful speaker was Susan Collins, Republican Senator from Maine. She began with an anecdote that was chilling. Noting that the event was sponsored by the Nancy and Paul Ignatius family, she looked up the name. St. Ignatius, Bishop of Antioch, was sentenced to be eaten by lions in the Roman Coliseum. Collins said that, sadly, being a moderate Republican in the Senate today means constantly avoiding such a fate.
Her description of the demise of civility in the Senate should be required reading for anyone trying to understand U.S. politics. Where once the words “colleagues” and “my friend” meant something, today, she said, it scarcely exists. In the past, Senators never went out to campaign against their colleagues, she said. Today, it happens all the time. How can you work with someone, build bridges and compromise when that person will personally work on your defeat, she asked rhetorically?
In the October 11th issue of the New Yorker, Ryan Lizza spells out the problem of political paralysis in Congress in much more detail using the failure of climate change legislation as is example.
But Canadians cannot afford to be smug as we watch the disintegration of political civility in the United States, certainly not when, as Jeffrey Simpson says, Prime Minister Harper’s “objective is not just to defeat but to obliterate the Liberal Party of Canada. For that purpose, the gloves are off all the time, from nasty attack ads against Liberal leaders to ritualistic, partisan punches from him and his ministers”.
Who will save us from the lions?